Sunday, December 3, 2023

"Shattered Myths: Unraveling the Heartbreak of the Israel-Palestine Conflict"



Every day, as you power up your TV, mobile, laptop, and other internet devices, the news pouring in from Gaza turns your stomach. The mutilated bodies beneath the rubble, the cries of injured children and elderly, grieving mothers, lifeless forms wrapped in makeshift coffins of aid blankets, and the overwhelmed hospitals—all paint a haunting picture of the agony inflicted by the Netanyahu-led atrocities on innocent Palestinians.

For decades, I remained indifferent to the Israel-Palestine Conflict until my Masters (MSc) days at Quaid-I-Azam University in Islamabad. In a course titled "Politics of the Middle East," I gained an academically informed and realistic perspective on the conflict. While many ordinary Pakistanis perceive Jews as enemies of Islam, this course revealed the dissent within the Jewish community itself. Orthodox Jews opposed the creation of Israel, protesting the Balfour Declaration in 1917, as they believed it contradicted their scriptures, foreseeing Jews scattered worldwide until the day of judgment.

It's crucial to distinguish between Zionism—a political philosophy advocating a separate Jewish state—and Judaism. Many Muslims worldwide struggle to differentiate between Zionists and Jews. Islam and Judaism share similarities in teachings, history, and scriptures, and historically, Muslim empires provided refuge to Jews escaping persecution.

The geopolitical stance of the UK and US in the Middle East, driven by pragmatism for their interests, has often supported oppressive regimes. This, in turn, suppressed democratic transitions, fostering dissent that eventually erupted in events like the Arab Spring and protests in Tahrir Square.

The atrocities committed by Hamas on October 7, 2023, were undeniably horrific, particularly against non-combatants, women, children, and the differently-abled. While these actions invite foreign intervention, it's essential to recognize that many extremist movements result from the policies of major global players.

The current conflict between Israel and Hamas shatters the notion that the 21st century heralds an era of growth, peace, and progress. It exposes the moral weakness of humanity, still grappling for common ground to prevent war and misery. It challenges the narrative of American resolve for democracy, human rights, and peace, revealing the influence of the military-industrial complex. To move towards peace, a united global effort to ban arms sales and support corporations profiting from war is imperative.

The war also dispels the myth of Muslims as a unified "Ummah." Cultural bonds, rather than religious identity, prove stronger in fostering cooperation and peace. The cries of bruised babies, mourning mothers, and devastated families in Gaza demand the attention of the world. How long can the civilized world justify this war, even in the face of Hamas using hospitals as sanctuaries? While Israel's actions are oppressive, expressing love, respect, and acceptance for Jews is essential. In a world consumed by talk of war, there must be voices championing peace, no matter how seemingly unrealistic in the contemporary world. As Lisa Fishman aptly put it, 'Mad world, mad kings, mad composition.'

Author: Zaheer Abbas Maseed, Chairperson @
HEELA Institute for Research and Development Islamabad

 

 

 

 


No comments:

Post a Comment